Holodomor as genocide and the inaccuracies of Mr. Shaban Murati

On May 18, the lower house of the French Senate recognized the Holodomor of 1932-1933 as genocide. The history of the Holodomor is known in the years 1932-1933 when Stalin and his regime in the USSR carried out the forced collectivization of villages in all the Soviet republics as well as in the Ukraine of that time. It is also known that the Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Republic of that time was a creation of the Bolsheviks in order to create a buffer state in the face of a future war with Nazi Germany. Holodomor, a Ukrainian word meaning a man-made famine between 1932-33, occurred during Joseph Stalin's reign over the Soviet Union and caused an estimated 3.5 to 5 million Ukrainian deaths. The perfect form of moryty is zamoryty, 'kill or put to death' In English, The Holodomor has also been referred to as artificial famine, famine genocide, terror famine, and terror genocide. The brutal efforts under Stalin to impose collectivism and suppress Ukrainian nationalism left an estimated 3.9 million dead. At the height of the Ukrainian famine of 1932-33 under Joseph Stalin, starving people roamed the countryside, desperate for something, anything to eat (Holodomor | Holocaust and Genocide Studies | College of Liberal Arts (umn.edu). Official figures say that at least 8 million Ukrainians lost their lives: 5.5 - 6 million civilians, and more than 2.5 million native Ukrainians were killed on the front during World War II. Figures range from 8 to 14 million killed, however, only 6 million have been identified (How many Ukrainians died in ww2? - Google Search). On May 18, 2023, so about 80 years after the terrible event, the lower house of the French Senate very late recognizes the Holodomor - that is, this event as Stalin's genocide against the peoples who lived in Ukraine, because it is known that he lived in the Ukraine of that time and in the Ukraine of today a mixed population where according to today's Wikipedia are: 77.8% Ukrainians; 17.3% Russians 4.9% Others (https://en.Wikipedia.org/wiki/Ukraine). So the Holodomor happened not only to Ukrainians, but to all layers of the population, including the Russian population in Ukraine. Ukrainian Foreign Minister Dmiri Kuleba thanked the President of France (convicted for corruption) and the lower house of the French Senate, writing: ``I am grateful to the French senators for this historic vote that restores justice and honors the memory of millions of victims. Such crimes must never be repeated and never forgotten. Dmitri Kuleba (The French Senate approves the recognition of the Holodomor as genocide (yahoo.com). Delays - in the definition of an event as genocide, are certainly related to political reasons and in relation to the relationship that the policies of the countries concerned have. There are many events that have not been approved by the French senate or by any other senate, such as the genocide of the Ottomans against the Armenians, etc., etc., genocides that happened a few years ago, but the genocide of the Serbs against the Kosovar Albanians that happened before in a few years, Mr. Shaban Murati will probably leave it for later to get a little old. Meanwhile, he has taken it upon himself to become more Catholic than the Pope and has gone even further: dealing only with Russia to show how pro-American he is. Even in 2006, the American Government authorized the establishment of the "Holodomor Genocide Memorial". On March 14, 20018, the US Senate passed a resolution recognizing the Holodomor as genocide. On November 25, 2022, on Holodomor Memorial Day, US President Joe Biden emphasized that "Holodomor is death by starvation, where Stalin's regime imposed brutal and repressive policies on Ukraine, including the creation of a deliberate famine in 1932-33 , which caused the disappearance of millions of innocent women, men and children". Other countries have also remembered about the Holodomor after 80 years, and the Americans probably remembered because of the Russia-NATO clash over Ukraine after the coup d'état in 2014. But History is different according to Mr. Shaban in his article today in Dita newspaper. He has stated that genocide was committed against the Ukrainian people by the Russians?!, and literally: "On May 18, 2023, the French Senate adopted a resolution, in which it recognizes the Holodomor as Russian genocide against the Ukrainian people. In March 2023, the Lower House of the French parliament adopted a resolution recognizing the Holodomor as a Russian genocide against the Ukrainian people, and further again: The Russian genocide against the Ukrainian people, which took place in the middle of Europe, is a massive crime of monster against humanity. (The Assembly to recognize the Holodomor as Russian genocide against the Ukrainian people - Gazeta Dita). The lower house of the French Senate has not expressed itself as Russian genocide", as his master Murat says, but as genocide by Stalin's regime, and if Mr. Shaban doesn't know History, Stalin was Georgian, the USSR had 16 republics and several hundreds of small populations, and the USSR had a communist regime, and recently in Ukraine from the Holodomor, a lot of Russians and other people who lived in Ukraine died together with the Ukrainians . You cannot blame an entire people for genocide, but the Stalinist regime and precisely one individual who was not actually Russian. Why Mr. Murat wants to show himself to be more Catholic than the Pope, knowing full well that not only Ukrainians suffered in that genocide, but also many other Russians, even on the other hand, the Bolshevik decision-making for this mass famine happened not only in Ukraine but also in all other republics of that time, because at the head of the CPSU was Stalin, and other non-Russian leaders such as the Ukrainian Khrushchev and Lithuanians, Estonians, Latvians, Poles of that Bolshevik government. This seems to show how anti-Russian and internationally good Mr. Murat, and that the US should take this writer into account, despite the fact that it distorts the words of the resolution of the lower house of the French senate. The Albanian Parliament should certainly undertake such an initiative, but before that it is in the honor of the Albanian Parliament to make and re-make a resolution to call as Genocide the actions of the Serbian state of Milosevic towards the Albanians of Kosovo before, together with the government of Albin Kurti. First, let our wound hurt us, and then, of course, the other's wound. We hope that such incidents do not happen again and that hatred leads nowhere but disaster. This seems to show how anti-Russian and internationally good Mr. Murat, and that the US should take this writer into account, despite the fact that it distorts the words of the resolution of the lower house of the French senate. The Albanian Parliament should certainly undertake such an initiative, but before that it is in the honor of the Albanian Parliament to make and re-make a resolution to call as Genocide the actions of the Serbian state of Milosevic towards the Albanians of Kosovo before, together with the government of Albin Kurti. First, let our wound hurt us, and then, of course, the other's wound. We hope that such incidents do not happen again and that hatred leads nowhere but disaster. This seems to show how anti-Russian and internationally good Mr. Murat, and that the US should take this writer into account, despite the fact that it distorts the words of the resolution of the lower house of the French senate. The Albanian Parliament should certainly undertake such an initiative, but before that it is in the honor of the Albanian Parliament to make and re-make a resolution to call as Genocide the actions of the Serbian state of Milosevic towards the Albanians of Kosovo before, together with the government of Albin Kurti. First, let our wound hurt us, and then, of course, the other's wound. We hope that such incidents do not happen again and that hatred leads nowhere but disaster. despite distorting the words of the resolution of the lower house of the French senate. The Albanian Parliament should certainly undertake such an initiative, but before that it is in the honor of the Albanian Parliament to make and re-make a resolution to call as Genocide the actions of the Serbian state of Milosevic towards the Albanians of Kosovo before, together with the government of Albin Kurti. First, let our wound hurt us, and then, of course, the other's wound. We hope that such incidents do not happen again and that hatred leads nowhere but disaster. despite distorting the words of the resolution of the lower house of the French senate. The Albanian Parliament should certainly undertake such an initiative, but before that it is in the honor of the Albanian Parliament to make and re-make a resolution to call as Genocide the actions of the Serbian state of Milosevic towards the Albanians of Kosovo before, together with the government of Albin Kurti. First, let our wound hurt us, and then, of course, the other's wound. We hope that such incidents do not happen again and that hatred leads nowhere but disaster. to make and redo a resolution to call as Genocide the actions of the Serbian state of Milosevic towards the Albanians of Kosovo before, together with the government of Albin Kurti. First, let our wound hurt us, and then, of course, the other's wound. We hope that such incidents do not happen again and that hatred leads nowhere but disaster. to make and redo a resolution to call as Genocide the actions of the Serbian state of Milosevic towards the Albanians of Kosovo before, together with the government of Albin Kurti. First, let our wound hurt us, and then, of course, the other's wound. We hope that such incidents do not happen again and that hatred leads nowhere but disaster.